Luat Viet

:: Question :: Shares of my Company are listed on the HOSE. The enterprise intended to increase its charter capital under the form of issuing additional shares to offer investors in 2009. Nevertheless, when the enterprise registered the dossier to increase its charter capital with the competent Planning and Investment Department, this competent authority did not accept the vote counting minutes, which collects the shareholders’ written opinion. As a result, the Planning and Investment Department requested the enterprise to supply the copy of the Minutes of the General Meeting of Shareholders of the Company. Please kindly advise how the law regulates this case?

Answer:

In accordance with the Article 104 of the Law on Enterprises 2005, the General Meeting of the Shareholders (the GMS) shall pass resolutions, which falls within its power by way of: (i) voting at meetings; or (ii) collecting written opinions and the resolutions, which are passed by way of collecting written opinions, shall be as valid and effective as the resolutions which are passed in the meeting of the GMS.

Nevertheless, in the event that the Charter of the Company does not regulate otherwise, the following resolutions of the GMS must be passed under the form of voting in meetings of the GMS in accordance with the Clause 2, Article 104 of the Law on Enterprises:

a) Amendment of or addition to the charter of the company;

b) Approval of the development direction of the Company;

c) Decision on classes of shares and the total number of shares of each class which  may be offered for sale;

d) Appointment, discharge or removal of members of the Board of Management and Inspection Committee;

e) Decisions on investments or the sale of assets valued at equal to or more than fifty (50) per cent of the total value of assets recorded in the most recent financial statement of the Company, if the charter of the company does not stipulate another percentage;

Therefore, unless the Charter of your Company provides otherwise, the Resolutions of the GMS relating to the increase in charter capital under the form of issuing additional shares to offer must be passed by way of voting in the meeting of the GMS, instead of collecting written opinions, as provided in item a and c above.

• » Question :: I am the Head of Inspection Committee of A Joint Stock Company. Due to some subjective and objective reasons and full performance of responsibility and role of a Head of Inspection Committee to ensure the maximum interest of shareholders, I would like to authorize another person to be the Head of Inspection Committee for a fixed period of time. Is this permitted by the law? How is procedure? (22/07/2009)
• » Question :: Company A is a Shareholder (“Shareholder A”) owning less than 5% of the shares in Company B – a joint stock company (Company B). Under an agreement between Shareholder A and Company B, Shareholder A shall have the right to nominate one representative to be the Chief of the Inspection Committee (Inspection Committee) in the Company B. Then, Company B shall elect such representative to be Chief of Inspection Committee. From a legal point of view, does this agreement break the law? While all the decisions still waiting for the approval of the General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS), what will we have to do if the 2009 GMS does not approve this agreement because of subjective idea of the Company B? In the agreement between both parties, which terms and conditions (if any) should we offer to guarantee our interest? (01/07/2009)
• » Question :: In the process of conversion of enterprises with 100% state owned capital into shareholding companies, how to choose strategic shareholders of such shareholding companies? (03/06/2009)
• » Question :: I am a shareholder of Joint Stock Company A, I would like to pose a question: “That Company A actively develops new projects out of Resolution of General Shareholders’ Meeting of 2008, including a series of projects in real estate is itillegal?” Which regulations should be complied for the legality in this case? Note that Article 24.4.7 of the Charter of this Company provided that: Board of Management approve all investment out of the operating plan and annual budget of the Company with the value exceeding 10% of annual operating budget. (25/05/2009)
• » Question :: In order to request to cancel the resolutions of General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS), in case the order and procedures for convening the GMS did not comply with Law on Enterprises and the charter of the company, how should shareholders or shareholder group do in this case? (19/05/2009)